words which, because of misunderstanding and misrepresentation have
a mystique and menace out of all proportion to their significance.
Dysplasia is a medical word which means the malformation of tissue or
organs, in this case, the bones of the hip joint, it follows, therefore,
that hip dysplasia is not a disease or an illness in the everyday understanding
of the words, more a description of the shape of the bones which make
up the hip joint.
Hip dysplasia cannot be detected visually, it is not possible to look
at dog and say “that dog has good hips” or “that dog
has hip dysplasia” The condition can not be identified or evaluated
without the use of radiographic equipment.
In order to establish the condition of a dog’s hips under the
Kennel Club/ British Veterinary Association
Scheme, the dog must first of all be x-rayed by a vet. This entails
the dog being laid on its back,
with its hind legs being stretched out straight and an x-ray photograph
being taken of its pelvic region,
all of which is completely painless to the dog.
The resultant x-ray plate is then submitted, by the vet, to the BVA,
where a panel of two suitably
qualified specialists assess the two dimensional image and score the
This consists of the panel allotting points from a set scale, devised
by the BVA, to various locations
throughout the joint, wherever there is considered to be an imperfection.
The points gained by each of the
dog’s hips individually is then totalled and the result is known
as the hip score.
This score is then recorded by the BVA and a copy supplied to the owner
of the dog and it is
subsequently published by The Kennel Club in one of its releases.
The scale of points used under the scheme relates to various locations
in both the pelvis where the cup lies and
the head of the femur which carries the ball. Starting from a base of
0, each perceived flaw in every part of the
joint is allotted points, up to a maximum of 53 in each hip. From this,
it can be seen that an ideal score is 0:0, indicating that the dog does
not have HD and any score above this indicates the degree of dysplasia
Since hip dysplasia is not an illness or a disease, in the generally
understood meaning of the words, hip scoring
does not offer a cure or a treatment, and is, in fact of no benefit
to either dog or owner, the procedure is only
of value to breeders and the veterinary profession.
In Germany. the scheme used by their authority, grades the dog’s
score from A to D, where A equates to
the BVA score of 0- 9, and is described as normal, B equals 0-15 and
is known as slight and so on,
which seems to be somewhat less judgemental.
Hip dysplasia became the focus of attention when it was established
that severe cases of the condition can give
rise to arthritic developments in the joint producing lameness or ultimately
complete disability and the
associated agony for the dog and distress for its owner. The object
of the scheme being to identify affected dogs
at an early age, avoid using them for breeding and thus hopefully eradicate
Unfortunately, the condition does not occur to any discernable pattern
and indeed it has not been established
to what degree it is hereditary and may also be attributable to other
causes such as feeding, environment or
trauma. Moreover, in the breeds which have been involved in the scheme
for many years and have had many thousands of dogs examined, it is probably
true to say that there has been very little alteration in the number
of dogs affected and the variation of the scores. In addition, since
dogs with a 0:0 hip score represent only a small percentage of the total
of dogs of all breeds scored, it could be inferred that HD is a normal
condition in the domestic dog.
The problem is further compounded by the fact that two low scoring parents,
which themselves are by low
scoring parents, can produce one or more pups in a litter which eventually
prove to have high scores and
conversely a high scoring parent can produce low scoring off-spring.
Moreover there are numerous instances
of dogs with very high hip scores living a long and active life and
never displaying any sign of discomfort.
The scheme has produced a figure known as the breed mean average, which
is an average of the hip score of
all the dogs in each breed which have been hip scored; in the case of
the Large Munsterlander this is currently 8
(as of 2017). Unfortunately since only a very small percentage of the
pups registered in each breed is actually
hip scored, this figure is of doubtful value.
However, breeders are advised to use the mean as a guide when planning